13 Cheesecake Of The Month Clubs (My Personal Favorite!)

cheesecake with text overlay "Cheesecake Of The Month Clubs"

Cheesecake is a perfect treat for anyone with a sweet tooth, and it’s my personal favorite type of pie, cake, treat…whatever. It’s amazing. There’s something decadent about the combination of flavor and texture. It’s why I’m so excited to introduce these cheesecake of the month clubs to you.

There are so many different variations! People come up with unusual flavor combinations all the time! Others might make slight recipe tweaks to create something that is simply amazing.

Rather than shopping for cheesecakes in your local area, what about cheesecake of the month clubs? These clubs provide regular deliveries of cheesecake, right to your door! You’re getting sweet treats without any hard work on your part. You may even receive flavors that you would never have tried any other way.

Table of Contents

Cheesecake Of The Month Clubs

PS. Cheesecakes are my personal favorite, but if you want to branch out you can try these cake clubs or cupcake clubs which are pretty good too.

PPS. You might also like these cheese of the month clubs.

Amazing Clubs Cheesecake of the Month Club

Amazing Clubs is well-known for its range of curated clubs. These clubs provide items from many different producers – rather than relying on a single company. It is a great way to experience various baking styles and some unique flavors.

Their cheesecake club provides you with roughly 1.5 pounds of cheesecake per month. This is roughly enough to serve 8 to 10 people. You also get a newsletter about your cheesecake selection each month.

The club provides a different flavor each month. The website provides a list of previous flavors, but upcoming cheesecakes are a surprise. The club costs $49.95 per month in most cases. A long-term membership will sometimes cost $48.95 or $47.95 per month when you pay in advance.

David’s Cookies Cheesecake Of The Month Club

The club provides a different cheesecake flavor each month.

David’s Cookies isn’t just a cookie company. They also offer some pretty great desserts, including cheesecakes. Once again, their club provides a different cheesecake flavor each month. This starts with Cookies & Cream in January then Strawberry in February.

The club starts out at $125 for 3 months. That averages out to $41.66 per month. The monthly price decreases with the longer club duration, getting down to $37.50 per month for a 12-month membership.

Eli’s Cheesecake Chicago Cheesecake of the Month Clubs

They provide a schedule of which cheesecake are you going to get for a particular month.

If you want some more variation, Eli’s Cheesecake Chicago could be a good club to consider. The company has a few different subscription types to consider. One is fairly typical, where you can order for 3, 6, or 12 months.

The 3-membership cost $165.00. You’ll be receiving a different cheesecake flavor each month. For January, April, July, and October, it’s Original Plain Cheesecake. For February, May, August, and November, it’s Chocolate Chip Cheesecake. And for March, June, September, and December, it’s Strawberry Cheesecake.

The 6-month membership costs $329.00. You’ll be receiving Chocolate Chip Cheesecake for January and July, Chocolate Chip Cheesecake for February and August, Strawberry Cheesecake for March and September, Cookie Crazy Cheesecake for April and October, Tira Mi Su for May and November, and Turtle Cheesecake for June and December.

And lastly, for the 12-month membership which cost $639.00, you’ll be receiving pretty much the cheesecake previously mentioned for the 3 and 6-month memberships (check out their website, they provided cheesecake images there). If for some reason the scheduled cheesecake to be sent out for a particular month is not available or out of stock, they will replace it with a similar item of equal or greater value.

Flying Noodle Cheesecake of the Month Club

This curated membership is another interesting option to try.

Flying Noodle is another company that focuses on curated subscription programs. In this case, they’re providing a cheesecake from a different bakery each month. Each cheesecake is large enough for 8 to 10 servings. You also get a newsletter with details about the selections.

You can sign up for 3, 6, or 12 months at a time, along with a seasonal subscription (4 shipments per year). The average monthly price ranges from $52.95 to $54.95, but you need to pay for your full membership up-front.

The 3-month version costs $149.85 in total, the 6-month version costs $293.70 and the 12-month version costs $575.40. If you want the seasonal club instead, you’ll be paying $199.80. While Flying Noodle doesn’t offer details about the cheesecake flavors that you can expect, you can be certain that they’ll taste amazing.

Decadence Gourmet Cheesecake of the Month Clubs

Decadence Gourmet doesn’t provide regular cheesecakes. They focus on cheesecakes in a jar instead. There are upwards of 16 gourmet flavors for these single-serving cheesecakes. They’re shipped frozen so that they’re perfect when it is time to eat them. The company also focuses on quality. This includes relying on the best ingredients to give you the best experience possible.

Their monthly program is simple. It provides you with a different flavor of cheesecake each month. You can sign up for 3 months, 6 months, or a full year. There aren’t any specific prices for those durations, as the price is based on the number of cheesecakes that you choose. The 3-month membership gives you a 15% discount on regular prices. This goes up to 20% for the 6-month version and 25% for the 12-month.

While details aren’t provided about your quantity options, the cheesecakes on the site are generally sold in packs of 6. This suggests that your subscription will work in a similar way.

Cheesecake Carousel 3 Month Club

This local club has cheesecake-related items, rather than just whole cheesecakes.

The club from Cheesecake Carousel is a pickup-only option, located in Charlotte, North Carolina. It is a 3-month club that costs $120 for the duration. The club is also very interesting, as each month features a different type of product.

You receive a whole cheesecake the first month, a box of caramel pecan cheesecake truffles the second month, and a dozen cheesecake minis in the third month. The cheesecake minis come in the most popular flavors, while you can select the flavor of the whole cheesecake yourself.

This idea could work well if you don’t just want full cheesecakes every month. The timing is a little unusual too, as you can’t just start your membership in whatever month you choose. Instead, the memberships run from January to March, April to June, July to September, and October to December.

CheesecakeDelivered.Com Cheesecake of the Month Club

These gourmet cheesecakes and other baked goods are made from the highest quality ingredients.

Cheesecakedelivered.com was founded in 2004 and has been delivering cheesecakes and other desserts ever since. Owner Ted G. is so confident with their sweets offerings that they offer a money-back guarantee if you’re not satisfied with your purchase.

Their gourmet cheesecake and other baked goods are made from the highest quality ingredients to ensure that they’re sending the very best your way. Their top-notch customer service will assist you if you need help with choosing a flavor, tracking your orders, or whatever questions you may have.

Cheesecakedelivered.com Cheesecake of the Month Club is available in 3, 6, and 12 months subscriptions. Pricing ranges from $130 up to $480 plus shipping fees. Each month you’ll get a new selection of freshly baked gourmet cheesecake by their taste-testing professionals.

Jazzy Cheesecakes Cheesecake of the Month Subscription

Jazzy Cheesecakes was founded in 2004 by Gerri Brown-Simmons, whose late uncle the specialty bakery was named after. They currently have over 75 different flavors of cheesecake including their signature items, the Cheesecake Duo (cheesecake with sheet cake layered in between) and the Cheesecake-Stuffed Apples (with layers of white chocolate and creamy cheesecake filling).

Aside from cheesecake they also make cupcakes, cookies, brownies, pies, cobblers, and more.

Their Cheesecake of the Month Subscription starts from $44.99 per month. You can opt to get it monthly, quarterly, or yearly. You’ll get to enjoy a chef-curated cheesecake each month that can serve 8 to 10 people (8 inches).

They ship the cheesecake every 15th of the month unless it falls on a weekend or holiday. If that’s the case they will ship on the next available business day. You’ll be billed monthly on the 11th day, so if you want to opt-out just do so by the 10th of the month to cancel your subscription.

Lauren’s Cheesecake of the Month Club

Lauren’s Cheesecake has ten varieties of made-to-order cheesecakes that are available in three sizes.

Lauren’s Cheesecake was inspired by Lauren’s brother who owns ‘Jeff’s Cheesecake’ in Humburg, Germany. With her sibling’s support and help, Lauren is now a wholesaler (mainly) to stores in and around Waterbury, Vermont. She has ten varieties of made-to-order cheesecakes that are available in three sizes. Lauren also accepts direct orders through her website and is now also offering a cheesecake of the month club.

The club costs $100 for a 6-month subscription – you save $50 dollars by being a member. Each month you’ll receive a different cheesecake – for instance, for the month of February it’s Raspberry Swirl, for April it’s Maple Creme, for May it’s Chocolate Swirl, and for August it’s Lemon.

The cheesecake is available in 4-inch size (2 servings) for $9, 6-inch size (6-8 servings) for $25, and 9-inch size (12-16 servings) for $40.

Lauren also offers a gluten-free option.

Cakes By Jeff The Chef Cheesecake Membership

Cakes By Jeff The Chef’s best-selling cakes include the Strawberry Cheesecake, Frosted Animal Cookie Cheesecake, Cherry Bomb, Turtle Cheesecake, and Oreo Cheesecake. Aside from cheesecakes, Chef Jeff also creates custom-made cakes for any occasion.

His monthly cheesecake membership costs $39.97 including the shipping costs. Monthly, you’ll get 3 4-inch cheesecakes of your choice, 1 bonus 4-inch new cheesecake flavor exclusive to members only, and 1 free silicone baking mat.

As members, you’ll also get to enjoy 25% off on all products and apparel plus 1 free 10-inch cheesecake on your birthday month.

Chef’s Edge Culinary

Chef’s Edge Personal Chef & Culinary Services offers a variety of delicious food, including dinners, treats, and cheesecakes. Their Cheesecake of the Month Club features a different flavor each month, including Girl Scout Cookie, Red Velvet, and Butterscotch.

The regular version of the club costs $120, while a gluten free version comes in at $140 instead. Details are seriously minimal for the club. It isn’t even clear how long your subscription lasts. That said, cheesecakes on the site normally cost $10, so a $120 subscription probably lasts a full year.

Bliss Bakery

There’s also Bliss Bakery. This company offers a full 9-inch cheesecake every month. These need to be picked up from the store in Texas (although Bliss Bakery plans to offer shipping at a later date).

The club page doesn’t provide any details about flavors, which might be because you’re picking the cheesecakes up. Doing so would allow you to simply choose a flavor at the time from the ones they have available.

This club is most useful as a way to save money on Bliss Bakery cheesecakes. You get a discount ranging between 10% and 15%, depending on the length of your subscription. The 12-month subscription provides an extra 10% in-store discount to sweeten the deal further.

As for pricing, you’re looking at $162 for the 3-month membership, $316.80 for the 6-month, and $612 for the 12-month.

Cheesecake Club

Our final entry, Cheesecake Club, makes it onto this list more for the name than anything else. The company offers new flavors every month, including exciting varieties like Bailey’s Irish Cream, Chocolate Covered Strawberry, and White Chocolate Raspberry.

The difference is that these cheesecakes aren’t shipped out monthly. You need to manually order them instead.

Needing to order the clubs each month isn’t ideal. Still, let’s face it, the approach isn’t that different from a regular cheesecake of the month club. It’s certainly worth trying if you love the flavors or styles of these cheesecakes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s The Cheapest Cheesecake Club?

Lauren’s Cheesecake is easily the cheapest subscription, coming in at just $100 for 6 months. That calculates to less than $20 per month. The club page doesn’t say how big the cheesecakes are. However, given the price, you probably get either a 4-inch or a 6-inch cheesecake.

The next cheapest is Cakes By Jeff The Chef, which costs just under $40 per month. This subscription ships out 3 cheesecakes each month (all 4 inches). There’s also a bonus monthly cheesecake flavor, plus a free 10-inch cheesecake on your birthday month.

Are The Cheesecakes Always Full Size?

Most companies ship out one large cheesecake per month, which often contains 8 to 10 servings. However, a few take a different approach. For example, Cakes By Jeff The Chef sends out multiple 4-inch cheesecakes, which gives you more flavors to enjoy.

Then there’s Decadence Gourmet, which focuses on small cheesecakes in jars. Cheesecake Carousel is a little different again. That subscription sends out a whole cheesecake the first month, followed by cheesecake truffles and then a dozen mini cheesecakes.

Those are just a few examples. You’ll need to check the fine print for each club to find out what you’re getting.

Are There Any Vegan Cheesecake Of The Month Clubs?

Vegan cheesecakes aren’t really cheesecakes at all, but there are still plenty of such products out there (plus recipes to make your own). Cheesecake clubs are a little behind the times, though, as none of them feature vegan cheesecakes.

Hopefully there will be more options in the future. In the meantime, you could try the vegan cupcake subscription from Not Pie. While this features cupcakes rather than cheesecakes, it does still give you a tasty vegan dessert that’s delivered straight to you.