Doing the old “seafood market near me” search can quickly get frustrating and exhausting, especially when you can never find what you’re looking for. It’s great to buy local when you can, but sometimes, the pickings are slim.
This is why it’s beneficial to buy fresh seafood online instead. Not only is their availability often much better, but the companies are often quite transparent on their website. This means you can know exactly where your fish are coming from, and you can find more sustainable fishers to buy from if that’s important to you.
If you’re worried about the fish not arriving fresh enough, don’t! Most online seafood providers package their fresh fish soon after catching, and they ship orders out immediately for next-day delivery.
Table of Contents
Where to Buy Fresh Seafood Online
- Lobster Anywhere
- Sizzle Fish
- Sitka Salmon
- Lummi Island Wild
- Browne Trading Company
- Vital Choice
- Farm 2 Market
- Seafood Crate
1. Lobster Anywhere
Lobster Anywhere has been offering live delivery of Maine lobsters since 1999. They pride themselves on offering a quality service with guaranteed overnight delivery for maximum freshness.
Their lobsters are caught locally by independent fishermen and are then processed at their sustainable fishery before being delivered right to you. In addition to fresh, live lobster they also offer lobster tails, lobster meat, lobster rolls, and complete lobster dinners.
Their dinners include lobster bisque or chowder, lobster and steaks, lobster and shrimp dinners, and much more. These dinners are great if you want an easy, pre-made lobster dinner for yourself but they also make fantastic gifts.
2. Sizzle Fish
The idea for Sizzle Fish was born when it’s founder was out on a run. He realized that seafood is not only a delicious and sometimes fancy meal to eat, but most of it is extremely healthy. From here, he began selling high-quality fresh seafood as a way to help and encourage people to eat healthily, live better, and train better.
The regular consumption of fish can help improve your performance while providing your body with many powerful and healthy compounds, including omega 3 fatty acids. It’s a delicacy but it’s also healthy food. Because of this, the company works hard to supply customers with only the best.
Their products include fresh fish such as salmon, halibut, cod, tuna, rockfish, rainbow trout, shellfish, and many more. You can also get smoked fish, crab cakes, calamari, and the like.
For help and inspiration, they also have a recipe section.
3. Sitka Salmon
Sitka Salmon began in 2011 when a professor and two students when to Alaska for a summer to learn more about protecting Alaska’s wild salmon population as well as their environment. This began a lifelong passion for Alaskan Sitka Salmon that has turned into a successful boat-to-table seafood company.
The company works hard to support local and independent fishermen and provide full transparency to their customers. When you sign up for their service, you can choose both the species of salmon you want as well as the fisherman you’d like to buy from.
You can enroll in the program for intervals of three to nine months, with the promise of a full refund if you’re not happy with the fish you receive.
4. Lummi Island Wild
Lummi Island Wild is dedicated to high-quality, fresh seafood as much as it is dedicated to sustainability. They are one of the ten most sustainable fisheries in the world, in fact. Firstly, they became a fully solar-powered operation in 2007 – the first in the world.
They also take every possible precaution to ensure no salmon caught are damaged or wasted. Once caught, the fish are rolled into a live well, spending only a few seconds out of the water. Any species not being targeted are then released back into the water and are allowed to swim away peacefully.
Their focus is on salmon but they also offer tuna, halibut, black cod, shellfish, and ikura caviar.
5. Browne Trading Company
Browne Trading Company is proud to offer a wonderful selection of world-class fresh fish, fine caviar, and premium quality smoked seafood. The company began in 1991 when Rod Browne sought to continue his family’s long-standing involvement in the seafood trade.
The company is known in America as one of the best sources for superb, top-quality, fresh seafood. They are most well-known for their caviar imports, but they sell a variety of delicious fresh fish as well. This includes halibut, salmon, trout, sea bass, red snapper, swordfish, and many more, both common and lesser-known.
They process and prepare the fish immediately after catching and ship your order for guaranteed next-day delivery.
6. Vital Choice
Vital Choice began in 2001 with wild Alaskan salmon as their first product. Today, they offer a variety of premium wild seafood from some of the best and most sustainable, well-managed fisheries from around the world.
They believe that being kind to the planet and our environment around us is just as important as providing a quality, healthy product. All of their fish are wild-caught and are never farmed, meaning they more nutritious as well as more supportive to local communities than farmed alternatives.
They offer a variety of products in their market in addition to their fresh fish, including canned fish, supplements, meat, soups, frozen berries, and more.
For those that want a regular supply of their fresh fish, however, they also offer their monthly subscription service. You can choose between a salmon-specific box or a variety box, and fresh seafood will be delivered to you monthly.
Rastelli’s is a large company that offers a huge variety of healthy, responsibly sourced proteins for delivery. This includes seafood as well as beef, poultry, and pork. Their selection of seafood includes salmon filets, crab cakes, king crab legs, wild-caught sea bass, wild-caught Icelandic cod, wild-caught shrimp, wild-caught tuna, and a salmon roast.
You can order any of these products a-la-carte and have them delivered in a one-time order, or you can purchase one of their curated boxes for more variety. They have a seafood sampler that includes a variety of fresh fish or choose something similar for their other categories of meat.
Rastelli’s is a great source for those who love a good variety of protein and want to always buy healthy products from an ethical, sustainable, responsible company.
8. Farm 2 Market
Farm 2 Market proudly offers some of the finest domestic farmed caviar on the market. The caviar is smooth, clean, and environmentally sound. It’s one of their biggest sellers, though they do have plenty of fresh fish available as well.
Their selection isn’t as large as some other companies, but they do guarantee maximum freshness. All fresh fish is packed immediately after being caught and shipped out the same day.
Their fresh fish options include halibut, salmon, tuna, trout, bass, and sockeye. They do offer some frozen fish, a few different fillets, and some pre-cooked options as well.
9. Crab Place
Crab Place has some of the best fresh crabs Maryland has to offer. They are the original online provider of Maryland crabs, selling them online and delivering them since 1997. They’re so iconic that even Oprah has praised their crab sauce.
Of course, you can get plain, fresh crabs that are easy to prepare and come with easy to follow serving suggestions and instructions.
If you want to mix things up a little but still want crab, they have several options you can pick from. They’ve got hard crabs, soft crabs, crab cakes, jumbo cakes, crab legs, king crab legs, and more. If you’re serious about their crabs, joining the VIP club will get you free shipping.
Things to Consider When Buying Fresh Seafood Online
Seafood is a delicious and versatile way to get a lot of good protein and nutrients, especially .when incorporated into your diet on a regular basis. But, if your seafood isn’t fresh enough or wasn’t a great fish to begin with, it won’t be a good experience.
So, it’s important to consider a few things before making a purchase
Depending on where they are in the world and what they have access to, different companies will sell different things. Some may specialize in crabs and only dabble in a few other fish, while others may work to source and sell every fish imaginable.
Keep this in mind when you’re shopping. Do you stick to one kind of fish or will you want them all at some point?
How Quickly They Ship
Make sure you’re aware of their shipping methods and policies. When buying fresh seafood online, it’s important that it ships right away and is delivered by the next day. It’s best to always go with a company that can guarantee this.
Even if you love cooking up fresh fish, you might not always want to put in the effort. Or, maybe you’d like to have some to store away for later. Either way, it’s nice when you can find a company that sells fresh seafood but also has the option to buy frozen, or even pre-cooked and prepared for you.