The idea of getting ice cream by subscription just sounds too good to be true. After all, ice cream isn’t something that you would expect to be delivered by mail. The whole idea sounds challenging anyway, as ice cream needs to be kept at a cool temperature.
Despite this, there is multiple ice cream of the month clubs out there. These work exactly like you would expect, delivering you a collection of cold treats every month.
Monthly clubs like this are convenient and that isn’t even the best aspect. Joining one of these programs gives you the chance to try new flavors of ice cream, including some that you won’t find in a regular store. You may even discover some new favorites in the process!
My top pick is eCreamery. You get the most flavors per month, and they’re fun/unique flavors without being too weird. Salt & Straw is also a very cool club, but they only deliver in some areas of the USA, and their flavors are a bit too weird for me. For example, right now they’re featuring bug ice cream (real crunchy bugs inside!) and pig’s blood ice cream.
What else would you expect from LA & Portland, right?
Ice Cream Of The Month Clubs
PS. Don’t be shy. Check out a cookie of the month club while you’re at it.
PPS. You know what goes well with ice cream? Cake.
eCreamery Ice Cream Flavors of the Month
eCreamery is a perfect club if you want to sample more than one flavor each month. They are a very high-quality company (featured on Shark Tank), and their entire focus is on ice cream, including many different options for gifts and for special occasions.
eCreamery’s Flavor of the Month Club offers a way to try out multiple different types of ice cream. With it, you receive 4 pints of ice cream every month. In fact, you get a selection of ice cream, gelato, and sorbet, which are all a little bit different.
The flavors you’ll get are unique and many are unusual, including caramel apple crisp, sea salt caramel brownie, and cinnamon. In fact, eCreamery often creates distinct flavors, ones that you will not find anywhere else. The flavors I listed above might not be around by the time you order your subscription, since they frequently change featured items, and their ICE CREAM CHEF (!) creates new items frequently.
Oh, and did I mention you can actually create your own flavors and order those too (not part of the club)?! You can become your own ice cream chef!
The club isn’t as expensive as you might expect either. A 3-month membership costs $194.97, which averages to around $64.99 per month. Not a bad price for 4 pints of ice cream to your doorstep each month. The monthly price stays roughly the same regardless of your membership duration and there is no month-to-month version.
Amazing Clubs Ice Cream Of The Month Club
If you can imagine a type of club, Amazing Clubs probably has it. The site has an extensive selection of different memberships, including this Ice Cream of the Month Club. The club focuses on small-batch gourmet ice cream. It provides you with 4 different types of ice cream each month, all in 1-pint containers.
Amazing Clubs mentions that ice cream always relies on fresh and all-natural ingredients. The site also highlights the flavors that have been included previously. However, there are few details about the companies that produce ice cream.
The club costs $77.95 per month on a month-to-month or a 3-month membership. You get a slight discount per month if you sign up for a 6-month or 12-month version.
Goldbelly Ice Cream Monthly Subscription
At $89.95 per month, the Goldbelly Monthly Ice Cream Subscription might make you hesitate. Even so, the subscription is well worth considering. It can include some extremely good flavors, like Cake Batter Vodka Martini ice cream. You’ll often receive pints of regular ice cream, but sometimes you might get ice cream sandwiches instead.
The club also provides more ice cream than most other options. You’re typically receiving between 5 and 6 pints of ice cream every month. This may include multiple flavors. In other cases, you’ll receive 6 to 24 ice cream sandwiches. The amount of ice cream is perfect if you want more than one person to enjoy the frozen treats.
Salt & Straw Seasonal Flavors Pints Club
Salt & Straw is another great company for ice cream. They feature many of the common flavors, as well as options that you won’t see as often, like Apple Brandy & Pecan Pie, Sweet Corn & Waffle Cones, and Strawberry Cilantro Lime Cheesecake. Though I told you about the weirdest options above, they do feature better-sounding flavors too like licorice & lavender, or pumpkin spice with rooibos tea.
While Salt & Straw does have stores in multiple locations, the company also has a strong local food feel, which is supported by the quality of its products.
Their Pints Club sends out 5 packs of ice cream every month. You can choose to receive the monthly flavors, best sellers, or dairy-free ice cream. A 3-month version of the membership costs $229, while a 6-month costs $427.50 and a 12-month is $801.
Jeni’s Pint Club
Unlike many other companies, Jeni’s Pint Club doesn’t ship out ice cream every month. Instead, the subscription offers 4 pints of ice cream every 3 months. This means that recipients get 4 deliveries of ice cream each year.
The deliveries will always contain 4 distinct flavors, with an emphasis on the most popular frozen treats from Jeni’s. The pints will often be ice cream, but you may receive frozen yogurts or sorbets instead.
The 3-month subscription costs $199. Then it’s $389 for the 6-month version and $759 for the 12-month one. Club members will get 4 pints of ice creams, frozen yogurts, and or sorbet. Sometimes, members will even get one or two sneak peek flavors before they’re available to the public.
Mc Connell’s Pint of the Month Club
McConnell’s has been providing the finest ice cream made from scratch for over 70 years now. They are a third-generation, family-run, start-up that is more than just an ice cream company. They are known for creating amazing, pure-flavored ice cream with the simplest ingredients.
Their ice cream contains no stabilizers, preservatives, or fillers – only the finest ingredients available locally including grass-grazed milk and cream and organic cage-free eggs.
McConnells’s Pint of the Month Club will give you special access to newly launched flavors. Members will also have the first taste of their newest or limited edition releases. The subscription is available in 3, 6, and 12-month memberships that cost $195, $389, and $780 respectively.
Each month, members will receive 4 pints of 4 different specially selected flavors. Boxes are shipped every third week of each month. They’ll remind you via email the week before the shipment with each month’s flavors.
Penny Lick Ice Cream of the Month Club
Penny Lick was founded by Ellen Sledge who believes that the best ice cream is the simplest. This means using dairy from local and ethically treated cows and sustainable whole food ingredients to make their ice cream – that is of course without artificial flavoring or coloring.
The company also adopted a policy of not using nuts or any products with nut contamination in making their ice cream. They want their products to be safe for everyone including those with nut allergies. Some of their ice cream flavors include Vanilla Bean, Milk Chocolate, Fresh Mint Chip, Chocolate Malt, Lavender Truffle, Dark Chocolate Coconut, and Sophisticated Smores.
Their Ice Cream Club comes in two different membership plans, the 3 pints for 3 months that cost $87 and the 5 pints for 3 months that costs $132. As of this writing, delivery is within Westchester and Fairfield counties only.
Each month members will enjoy best-selling and surprise ice cream flavors. They’ll also get exclusive club-only flavors.
Full Tilt Ice Cream Pint of the Month Club
Full Tilt Ice Cream was founded by Ann Magyar and Justin Cline in 2008 and has since been making all-natural ice cream and frozen desserts. They make the most out of local ingredients combined with creativity to produce amazing and deliciously flavored ice cream.
Some of the flavors they offer include Salted Caramel, Thai Iced Tea, Huckleberry Chip, Peppermint Hot Chocolate, Blueberry Crumble, and Ube. They also have vegan options like Vanilla, Salted Popcorn, and Chocolate.
They currently have three locations spread across Seattle, Washington: White Center, Columbia City, and Ballard.
Their Pint of the Month Club is a 12-month subscription with pricing starting at $80. Each month members will get to taste unique flavors that are exclusively for club members only.
Shaws Ice Cream Pint of the Month Club
The new owner Diana Zogaric successfully reopened Shaws last January 18, 2021, in San Francisco, California. Shaws has been famously serving Mitchell’s ice cream but this time around they also function as an in-store event space and offer mobile ice cream parties, party favors, event displays, and gift baskets.
They carry San Francisco’s tastiest ice cream made from 16% butterfat cream. There are plenty of flavors to choose from – 17 year-round flavors along with one or two seasonal offerings, and a revolving Flavor of the Month. Some of the flavors include Caramel Praline, Chocolate Caramel Crackle, Espresso Toffee Crunch, Grasshopper Pie, Macapuno, Red Raspberry Sorbet, Thin Mint, and Ube.
Their Ice Cream Pint of the Month Club is a 12-month subscription that costs $75 with free shipping. That’s 22% savings for a total of $21. You can also opt for store pick-up if you’re around the area. Club members can choose from the 17 year-round flavors offerings or Mitchell’s ‘Flavor of the Month.’
Most of their ice cream is gluten-free and does not contain eggs.
Jupiter Moon Ice Cream’s Ice Cream Explorers Club
Aside from making really amazing handcrafted ice cream, Jupiter Moon Ice Cream is also, according to them, a space for joy and happiness. They created a place where celebrations whether big or small, can amplify the positive feeling of everyone in the room. Aside from ice cream, they also offer ice cream floats and sundaes.
They are dedicated to finding and using only the best ingredients – locally sourced as much as possible, and sustainably produced, in making their artisan ice cream. They have 20 ice cream flavors that constantly get updated to include non-dairy and vegan options. They also have freshly baked waffle cones available to hold your ice cream.
Their Ice Cream Explorers Club Membership is available in 3, 6, and 12 months subscriptions. An official membership card, a handy cooler tote, and an ice cream scooper are included in the gift box of every subscription. Ice Cream Explorers are the first to taste any new flavor releases and will also get access to exclusive flavors. Interestingly, the subscription provides 3 pints and 6 waffle cones each month, rather than just pints.
This subscription is for pickup only at their shop in St. Joseph, Minnesota and starts on the second Thursday of each month.
Purple Door Ice Cream Pint Club
Purple Door Ice Cream is a husband and wife venture that launched in 2011. Lauren and Steve Schultz eventually opened their retail scoop shop in 2014 and soon after opened two more satellite scoop shops in 2018.
Today they offer over 200 flavors of ice cream, 24 of which are available in pints. They are committed to using local ingredients whenever available in their bid to support the community and its small businesses – in fact, they partner with many local Milwaukee companies.
Their Pint Club is a yearly subscription where members will receive four Purple Door pints delivered 4 times a year. The subscription cost is $240 and the packages are shipped in February, May, September, and November.
Members will get to enjoy a selection of 4 of their best-selling ice cream pints. Occasionally they will also include a seasonal flavor, a sorbet, or a surprise flavor. Unfortunately, they don’t allow flavor substitutions or requests.
Purple Door also offers catering which is available in full-service packages and pick-up packages.
Norwood Ice Cream & Candy Company Pint Club
Norwood Ice Cream & Candy Company prides itself in offering the freshest products – they spend hours making new small batches of frozen treats using only quality ingredients. These ingredients are sourced within the community so they can attest to their quality and freshness. For one, Norwood Ice Cream & Candy Company doesn’t believe in using preservatives and other artificial ingredients.
Some of their classic flavors are Salted Caramel Chip, Coffee Toffee, and Vanilla Bean. Pumpkin Spice, Maple Pecan, and Roasted Apple & Riesling Sorbet are some of their Fall Season Flavors. For Summer Seasonal Flavors they have Roasted Balsamic Strawberry, Lemon Blueberry, and Peach Melba to name a few.
Their Pint Club has three different options: a 3-Month Subscription for $62, a 6-Month Subscription for $125, and a 12-Month Subscription for $250. Prices are not inclusive of tax. You can enjoy 15% and 20% savings for the 6 and 12 months subscription.
Each month, members will receive 1 pint of the Pint Club flavor and 1 pint of their own choosing. You will have to mark the particular flavors that you prefer upon checkout – some of the choices include Lemon Poppyseed, Cardamom Cold Brew, Wild Blueberry Cobbler, Mango Margarita Sorbet, and Sugar Plum Fairy.
Shipping isn’t available, so the ice creams need to be picked up from the company’s store in Eldersburg, Maryland.
Urban Churn Ice Cream Club
Urban Churn by Adam Brackbill is an ice cream company that uses all-natural ingredients and local produce to make its products. Their ice cream flavors and other desserts are inspired by family recipes and tradition.
They want to be identified as that small business neighborhood ice cream shop, that is very involved in the community. They do this firstly by partnering with local farms and dairy farmers.
Aside from ice cream, they also have a dessert menu that incorporates ice cream in it, for instance, they have Banana Bourbon Split and Lemon Bar Sundae.
Urban Churn Ice Cream Club costs $32 for a one-year subscription. Members will receive $1 off per item on both website and shop purchases, free ice cream, and discounts monthly, and will also be the first to be notified of any new flavor releases or first in line to pre-order.
Their website seems fairly new and some of the information is not available, however, they are pretty active on Facebook so it’s probably best to reach out to them via that channel.
Related Content
- Related: Best Fast Food Ice Cream
Frequently Asked Questions
Is There A Cheap Ice Cream Of The Month Club?
The cheapest option on this list is Urban Churn’s Ice Cream Club, which costs just $32 per year. It doesn’t really count though, as the club doesn’t send out ice cream regularly. You get discounts instead, plus some free ice cream in-store. However, specifics about the club are very limited.
Shaw’s Pint of The Month Club is exceptionally good. This one costs just $75 for a full year’s subscription, which calculates to $6.25 per month. There’s a catch, though – you need to present the card in-store to get your ice cream, so the club is only useful if you live in San Francisco.
You’ll need to pay a bit more if you want a company that ships ice cream to you. Purple Door is an excellent choice. Their yearly subscription is much pricier – at $240. However, it ships out 4 pints of ice cream each quarter, so the price per pint is very reasonable.
Which Clubs Have The Most Variety?
eCreamery is exceptional for variety, giving you 4 pints every month. The flavors always change and often include a combination of classics and new seasonal flavors. You’ll usually receive gelato and sorbet as well, which makes the club even more exciting.
Does Ben & Jerry’s Have An Ice Cream Club?
Despite their popularity, Ben & Jerry’s doesn’t currently offer an ice cream club. But, they do allow you to order online through delivery partners like Doordash, GrubHub, Postmates, and the like. This ice cream is delivered from local stores, so you should get it quickly.
The Ben & Jerry’s website has a gift shop as well, which allows you to order ice cream for 2-day delivery. This approach gives you the largest range of flavors without that much extra waiting time. You might even find flavors that aren’t stocked at your local store.
22 Foods To Replace Junk Food
Leave a Reply