It may not have been called a bagel in 1394 in Poland, but even when called by another name, obwarzanek, a bagel is still a bagel. Though it's been around for centuries, the bagel didn't come to the US until the late 19th century from Eastern Europe.
Despite the bagel not originating here, it didn't take long before it gained strong roots, especially in New York. Now you can get delicious, New York style bagels wherever you are in the USA with a bagel of the month club.
Are you wondering why today's article is based on New York bagel club subscriptions? It's because you would be hard-pressed to find a bagel of the month club anywhere else.
There are two main reasons why New York seems to be the bagel capital of the US. First, is because of the large Jewish Polish community, bagels have been a long-time staple in the Jewish culture.
In Medieval Europe, the Catholic church banned the Jewish community from baking bread. To get around this law, the Jewish people boiled their bread instead. Finding that smaller bread and ones with holes in the middle cooked more evenly, the bagel was invented.
The second reason the bagel has found its home in New York is because of the water. Based on an article in the Smithsonian Magazine, the water makes the bagels taste and texture better because of all of its unique components.
New York receives its water from the Catskill Mountains. The water is softer and contains less calcium and magnesium than water found in other regions. Due to the lower mineral content, the gluten protein in the dough isn't as strong, creating the perfect soft texture found only in the New York bagel.
Of the clubs below, I think the best one is going to be AmazingClubs Bagel of the Month Club. Amazing Clubs is well known for their legit, gourmet products shipped out consistently each month, and they're getting really good reviews for their bagel club! I like this club because you get bagels shipped from a VARIETY of bagel makers in New York, rather than just one bakery.
Table of Contents
Bagel of the Month Clubs
- Amazing Clubs
- New Yorker Bagels
- New York Bagel and Buns
- Bagel Biz.com
- Best New York Bagel.com
Bagel Gift Baskets
- Zabar's
Bagel of the Month Clubs
Amazing Clubs
Amazing Clubs offers a wide variety of club options, including foods, condiments, beverages, neckties, and Teddy bears. They have a club for just about anyone of any age.
Amazing Clubs started in 2003 when the founders realized the need for a great online company that offered an array of high-quality product subscriptions. Starting with just one club, they grew to a top-rated business that now offers 40 different products, including a bagel of the month club.
Though they are not in New York, they only select top authentic New York bagels. Every month the recipient will receive:
- 16 bagels – Eight each of two new flavors each month
- Bagel Lovers Newsletter information about the bagels included in that month's delivery, bagel fun-facts, and serving recommendations
- Free shipping
- You choose when the first shipment goes out
- Choice of payment – Month to Month or Prepay
- 3 Month Club – $42.95/Month
- Seasonal Every 3 Months – $42.95/Month
- 6 Month Club – $41.95/Month
- 12 Month Club – $40.95/Month
New Yorker Bagels
New Yorker Bagels got its start fifty years ago under the name of The Bagel Buffet in Greenwich Village. The Bagel Buffet was started by two immigrants looking to capture the American dream.
Because of their great success with the Bagel Buffet, the family opened another bagel company, New Yorker Bagels. New Yorker Bagels only sells wholesale and has no storefront. Though they are still a family run business, they are now the world's largest bakery for fresh bagels in the world.
If you are interested in sampling their hand-rolled bagels, they do offer free overnight delivery on all of their fresh bagels. If you're already an enthusiast of the New Yorker Bagel, then you might like their bagel of the month club membership to receive your monthly bagel fix.
New Yorker Bagels offers 3 Different subscription options. The Custom and Specific Flavor clubs include the ability to:
- Change frequency
- Pause membership
- Change your next delivery date
- Receive a 10% discount on all automated orders
- Cancel anytime
Custom Bagel of the Month
- You select four flavors and quantities of each flavor
- Choose between 12 ($39.50/delviery) or 36 bagels ($74.79/ delivery)
- Change flavors between deliveries
- Select frequency of deliveries, options include every 1-4 weeks or every 1-4 months
Specific Flavor Subscription
- Choose your favorite bagel flavor
- Includes 12 bagels ($35.55/ delivery)
- Choose the frequency of the deliveries 1-6 weeks or months
The Bagel of the Month Gift
- Bagel flavors are preselected
- The membership is paid in advance
- Membership lengths available are 3, 6, 9, or 12 months
- 3 Gift Options
- Classic 12 bagels – 3 each of the following Plain, Sesame, Poppy, and Cinnamon Raisin
- Surprise Bagel of the Month 12 bagels – the baker will choose from the 24 available flavors and select 4 different flavors each month
- Mini Bagel of the Month 36 mini bagels – 3 flavors included in each shipment are Plain, Sesame, and Everything
New York Bagel and Buns
New York Bagel and Buns was established in 1993, in Farmingdale, NY. They operate as both a convenient online store as well as a friendly neighborhood bakery under the name of the Bagel Hut.
In addition to their yummy bagels, they also offer an array of other baked goods such as:
- A variety of crumb cakes
- Muffins
- Brownies
- Croissants
- A dozen different flavors of cream cheese
- Lox
But the star of the show is their bagels! They have 24 different flavors anywhere from the classics like Plain and Sesame to the more unique such as the Rainbow or French Toast options.
Additionally, they have a couple of other unique bagel-spinoffs like their:
- Bialy – Small traditional Jewish Polish roll
- Flagel – Flattened Bagel
- Twists – Braided Bagel Loaf
New York Bagel of the month club is a fabulous way to try their bagels. There are three subscription options. All of the memberships are available as 1-12 month options.
- Bagels of the Month Bakers Dozen – $13.20 + Shipping
- Thirteen assorted bagels delivered every month
- Bagel of the Month 31 – $32.95 + Shipping
- 31 assorted bagels delivered every month
- Bagel of the Month Classic – $38.95 + Shipping
- 12 Assorted Bagels
- 2-8 ounce containers of plain cream cheese
- 1-8 ounce container of vegetable cream cheese
- 4 Black and White cookies
Bagel Biz.Com
The Bagel Biz story begins in 1986 with their original bagel bakery, Dan's Bagel Cafe in East Meadow, New York. Realizing that their bagels were in high demand and wanting to share their delicious round treats with more people, they opened a second bakery in 1995.
The Bagel Biz was that second bakery. This time they serviced the local commercial and residential area of Melville, New York. After successfully launching their second bakery, they learned that their bagels were ready to go nationwide, and they introduced the country to their online store.
The Bagel Biz now ships thousands of bagels all around the country every day. You can order bagels as a one-time shipment or set up a monthly bagel subscription.
There are three different subscription quantities available, 12, 24, or 36 bagels.
- 12 Bagels – $39.98/ delivery
- 24 Bagels – $44.98/ delivery
- Add 12 more for only $5
- 36 Bagels – $77.98/ delivery
Each delivery is comprised of:
- A new variety each month
- Charges will appear the 1st of each month
- Can be sent anywhere in the US
- Cancel anytime
- Shipping not included but calculated at checkout
Best New York Bagel.com
Best New York Bagel.com was inspired when a New York Firefighter spent time away from New York and realized the nation's lack of a tasty traditional New York style bagel.
The owner and founder's goal is to bring amazing bagels “…to your doorstep in a timely fashion, in a professional manner at a respectable price, all with a few clicks of the mouse!”
Best New York Bagel.com is strictly an online store specializing in sharing New York's most delectable bagels with the country. There are five different bagel club options. Shipping is not included in the price.
- Weekly Delivery of a dozen New York Bagels with Specialty Flavors ($25.95-$190.21)
- You pick 2 different flavors – 6 of each or you can choose “A Mix of Flavors”
- Week to Week or 2, 4, or 8-week Prepay
- Monthly Delivery of 12 Flat Bagels ($26.95-$279.72)
- Three choices of flavors or the mix
- Month to Month or 3, 6, or 12-month prepay
- Monthly Deliver of 12 Onion Flavored NY Bialys ($25.95-$298.20)
- Month to Month or 3, 6, or 12-month prepay
- Bi-Weekly Delivery of a dozen New York Bagels ($26.95-$278.72)
- You pick 3 different flavors – 4 of each or you can choose “A Mix of Flavors”
- 2 Weeks or 4, 8, or 16-week Prepay
- Monthly Delivery of a dozen New York Bagels ($26.95-$278.72)
- You pick 3 different flavors – 4 of each or you can choose “A Mix of Flavors”
- Month to Month or 3, 6, or 12-month prepay
Bagel Gift Baskets
Zabar's
During the search for the best bagel of the month clubs, Zabar's came up, and though they don't offer a monthly membership, they are definitely worth noting for their fabulous bagel gift basket.
In 1934 Louis and Lillian started Zabar's a small neighborhood deli style store, and they are now a third-generation family-run business. They offer a variety of goods, including:
- Freshly roasted coffee
- Smoked fish
- Caviar
- Artisanal Cheeses
- Bread and Baked Goods
- Gift Baskets and Boxes
- Housewares
What once started as a 22-foot wide shop has now expanded to encompass almost a full block. But if you can't make it to New York to check out their market, don't worry, they can ship anything you would like from their online store.
There are a few different bagel gift options, including bagel boxes and bags. However, if you are looking for a gift that will impress the recipient, checkout their Zabar's Morning Basics Basket. The gift basket contains:
- 6 Original Zabar's Bagels
- 1/2 pound of Nova Lox
- Zabar's Plain Cream Cheese
- 1/2 lb. Zabar's Ground Special Blend coffee
- Cinnamon rugelach (It's the family recipe)
- Coffee Mug
- Hamper with a red checked napkin
Leave a Reply