• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to after header navigation
  • Skip to site footer
Food For Net Logo (Realistic)

Food For Net

  • Original Recipes
  • Recipe Roundups
  • Beer
  • Whiskey
  • Wine
  • Subscription Boxes
  • Meal Delivery
  • Outdoor Cooking

The Best Rum For Baking

November 7, 2021 by Food For Net
Home ‣ Spirits ‣ The Best Rum For Baking
Two types of baking made with rum and two bottles of rum

Rum is an intricate, diverse spirit with all kinds of amazing flavors to discover. This is often done by sipping it neat or making cocktails, but this isn’t all you can do with rum. It’s featured in several desserts, you can make a nice sauce with it or add it to your baked goods! Perhaps the most notable method here is rum cake. 

Despite its worldwide popularity, rum cake is actually a traditional holiday dessert in the Caribbean, descended from holiday puddings. In the original recipe, dried fruit would be soaked in rum for several months. Only after much time had passed would the dried fruit be added to dough that’s been prepared with sugar and caramelized. Of course, there are several different ways to make it now, but the common denominator is always rum. 

The best rum for baking is without a doubt dark rum. Dark rum is aged and has many aromas, flavors, and nuances to offer. In addition, you don’t want anything that’s too sweet. Look for warm flavors notes like vanilla, oak, and caramel, balanced by spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, or cloves. Whether it’s rum cake you’re after or something else, a warm, mildly spicy dark rum is the way to go. 

Table of Contents

Toggle
  • Best Rum For Baking
    • 1. Brugal Anejo Gold
    • 2. Bacardi Gold
    • 3. Sailor Jerry 
    • 4. Pusser’s British Navy 
    • 5. Myers Original Dark Rum 
  • Easy Rum Cake Recipe

Best Rum For Baking

1. Brugal Anejo Gold

Brugal Anejo Gold

Brugal is a popular brand of rum in the Dominican Republic, where they produce plenty of excellent rum. Brugal Anejo Gold is aged for about six years in American oak casks that used to hold bourbon. The distillation process is thorough and removes much of the heavy alcohol that many other rums leave behind.

It’s been masterfully blended to create a deep, rich rum that does amazingly well in rum cocktails. It’s most often used for mixing, but many enjoy taking a few sips as well. 

The aroma is light and classic with notes of dark brown sugar, caramel, buttery toffee, vanilla, and a little peppery spice. While pretty traditional for a rum, it’s well-balanced and delightful. The palate brings a clean, smooth mouthfeel that isn’t too sweet. Buttery flavors greet you on the entry with a hint of caramel, spice, and oak in the background. 

These spicy, oaky, buttery flavors are what makes it perfect for baking – it adds depth and flavor to your dish without getting carried away with sweetness. 

A glass jug and a glass that both contain buttermilk or perhaps one of the many substitutes for buttermilk

Substitutes For Buttermilk

Three images that look at how to use fresh yeast, including blocks of yeast, a bowl where dough is rising, and some freshly baked bread.

How To Use Fresh Yeast

A collection of different types of muffins in a pile, including chocolate chip, banana nut, and berry muffins.

27 Scrumptious Types Of Muffins You Won’t Want To Pass Up

Two large glasses filled with fruity mai tai, with fruit and umbrellas as a garnish

The Best Rum For Mai Tais

Two bottles of black Bacadi

The Best Bacardi Rum For Every Budget

Two rum cocktails with ginger beer, ice and lim

The 26 Best Rum Cocktails That Are Fun And Taste Fantastic

A black bowl containing one of the listed substitutes for baking soda

7 Practical Substitutes For Baking Soda

Someone using a baking subscription box at home, adding butter into their mixture

13 Baking Subscription Boxes To Get Your Kitchen Humming

2. Bacardi Gold

Bacardi Gold

Well-known for their rum around the world, Bacardi has an expression for just about anything. Within their collection you can find rums to mix up any cocktail you can imagine and even some that are good for sipping. Bacardi Gold is a versatile bottle that also does well in the kitchen with its aged flavors and mellow character. Matured in toasted oak barrels, its unique profile comes from a secret blend of charcoals that Maestros de Ron Bacardi holds close. 

In addition to impressive rum, the Bacardi family has an impressive story. They began producing rum in Cuba in 1862 and lived through a revolution as well as the American prohibition, which brought many wild nights to Cuba as travelers came in search of alcohol. After much political strife, they had to move and restart in Puerto Rico, where they rebuilt their business and eventually reached even higher heights than before. 

The nose offers delicate notes of butter and nuts while the palate is rich with toasted vanilla, bananas, orange peel, and buttery caramel. The finish is dry with sweet notes of oak. 

3. Sailor Jerry 

Sailor Jerry

Sailor Jerry Rum was created by the famous tattoo artist known as “Sailor Jerry” Collins. The recipe has undergone some changes over the years, but they’ve settled on a smooth, enticing, and moderately spicy profile. It’s good for sipping if you like a little kick in your glass, but it does exceptionally well in many cocktails, with the spicy mojito being a prime example. 

If you’re not into the spicy profile, however, you can add some sweetness back in by dropping some sugar and vanilla essence into the bottle and shaking it up. The smooth, spicy profile is perfect for baking, though, as it adds complementary flavors and doesn’t overwhelm the dish with sugary sweetness. 

Oak, tobacco, and vanilla greet you on the nose, followed by vanilla, butter, cinnamon, oak, ground ginger, and nutmeg on the palate. The vanilla and oak add softness and warmth to the palate, ensuring the spice doesn’t overwhelm without making it too sweet. It’s well-balanced and ready for whatever you want to make with it! 

4. Pusser’s British Navy 

Pusser’s British Navy 

Pusser’s British Navy is the perfect choice for when you want to splurge. There’s no denying that quality does matter even when you’re cooking or baking with rum, and this one will never fail you. Aged for 15 years, it’s known as a “navy rum” and the recipe is rooted in more than 300 years of history and tradition.

Around the time of 1655, it was common practice to give sailors a small, daily portion of rum. This gave them a little courage, comfort, and generally helped them deal with life on a ship. The one handing out this ration became known as the “pusser,” hence the name of this authentic navy rum. Distilled in wooden stills and aged in charred bourbon barrels, the final result has many unique flavors. The nose is sweet and warm with notes of molasses, sugar, caramel, dried fruit, and an array of spices. The palate is full and well-rounded with notes of tobacco, leather, vanilla, and spices. The finish is warm, long, and smooth. 

It may seem like an excessive purchase if you’re plan is mostly to bake, but most recipes don’t call for much rum, meaning the bottle will last and you will notice a difference with quality like this. 

5. Myers Original Dark Rum 

Myers Original Dark Rum 

Founded in 1879 by Fred L. Myers, Myers Original Dark Rum is a Jamaican expression that represents more than 140 years of Caribbean pride, history, and heritage with its classic flavors and commitment to quality. It was the dedication of the original family members that drove this brand to its success, and the company still works hard to this day, honoring its roots with expert practices and only high-quality ingredients. 

The rum is made from pure sugarcane juice that’s been boiled into molasses and fermented. It’s distilled using both pot and continuous methods before maturing for about four years in white oak barrels. 

It has a rich, earthy profile with sweet and peppery spice on the palate with notes of butter, sugarcane, honey, leather, caramel, and dark chocolate, with raisins and figs on the background. Oak and smokiness arise on the finish. 

Easy Rum Cake Recipe

close up of a round, sugared cake on a white plate to represent the best rum for baking

While rum cake is not the only thing you can bake with rum, it’s certainly the most common and most popular. Though the recipe dates back many decades, you don’t have to soak the fruit for months before you enjoy your tasty treat. The following recipe is a great starter rum cake that uses some prepackaged ingredients. You can make the cake and pudding from scratch if you prefer a more customized, authentic feel! 

Ingredients: 

  • 1 package of cake mix (18.25 ounces ideally) 
  • ½ cup dark rum
  • 1 cup chopped walnuts or nuts of choice
  • 4 eggs
  • ½ cup of water
  • ½ cup vegetable oil
  • 1 package of instant vanilla pudding mix (3.5 ounces ideally)

For the glaze: 

  • ½ cup of butter
  • ½ cup of water 
  • ½ cup of white sugar
  • ¼ cup of rum 

Instructions: 

  1. Preheat the oven to 325 degrees F. 
  2. Grease and flour a 10-inch bundt pan or tube. 
  3. Mix the cake mix, eggs, rum, half cup of water, oil, and vanilla pudding mix until well-combined. 
  4. Pour this batter over nuts into the pan. 
  5. Bake for one hour and let cool. 
  6. Invert the baked cake on a serving platter and prick the top of it. 
  7. To make the glaze: Melt the butter in a saucepan, add ⅛ cup of water, and your ½ cup of sugar. Boil this for five minutes, stirring constantly. Remove from heat and stir in the rum. 
  8. Drizzle glaze over the upturned cake, letting some run down the sides as well. 

Make plenty of holes in the cake and ensure your rum glaze gets into every last one – this enhances the flavor so much! This recipe makes a full-sized cake that serves approximately 12 people, so scale down accordingly if you wish. If you’re new to rum cake, make a few smaller batches with different rums to see how the rum changes the flavor! You could also use one rum in the cake batter and another in the glaze if you’re feeling adventurous and want to mix some flavors! 

Category: SpiritsTag: Baking, Rum
A glass of dark n stormy cocktail with rum

The Best Rum For a Dark ‘n’ Stormy

A wooden spoon with shortening or one of many substitutes for shortening

Substitutes For Shortening

A small white dish of brown rice flour on a bed of brown rice, looking at different substitutes for brown rice flour

Substitutes For Brown Rice Flour

Cupcake Of The Month Clubs featured image

16 Cupcake Of The Month Clubs That Are Too Good To Ignore

A glass of the best Puerto Rican rum being poured from a shaker

The Best Puerto Rican Rum

A hand holding a glass of aged rum

The Best Aged Rum

Bottles of different types of vegetable oil laid out on a table, highlighting the different substitutes for vegetable oil.

Substitutes For Vegetable Oil

Four different sets of toppings for sourdough, which are just a few examples of sourdough bread flavor combinations

33 Stunning Sourdough Bread Flavor Combinations

Previous Post:A wooden bowl of blueberries on a bright blue backgroundAre Blueberries Good For You?
Next Post:Are Avocados Good For You?Avocados and avocado halves on a lime green background

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar

About The Owner

cooking bbq pizza outside

Hi! My name is Rick and foodfornet.com is just a website about food and drink that I like. That includes sous vide, slow cooking, grilling, smoking, and homemade pizzas.

I also make my own beer, wine, cider, kombucha, and sake… and am a whiskey enthusiast! 🍕🍺🥩🥃

A mojito on the table, next to a jigger, a cocktail shaker, and some limes

The Best White Rum For Every Budget

Someone pouring moonshine from a jug, highlighting the question of how to make moonshine.

How To Make Moonshine, And What Is Legal Moonshine?

Five glasses of gin and tonic with ice and different garnishes

The Best Gin For Cocktails

Two small shot glasses of tequila or mezcal in ice surrounded by limes, highlighting the comparison of tequila vs mezcal

Tequila Vs Mezcal: Production, Aging, And Flavor

The Best Honey Whiskeys

The Best Honey Whiskey

Two glasses of apple brandy next to a basket of apples and a few apples on a cloth

The Best Apple Brandy

Gourmet Food

Artisanal Beverages

Comfort Food

Comfort Food (Featured Image)

Copyright © 2025 Food For Net
Privacy Policy · Cookie Policy · Affiliate Disclosure · Accessibility Statement
Blog · Instagram · Twitter · Pinterest

FoodForNet.com is a member of the Amazon Associates affiliate program. We earn commissions from qualifying purchases through affiliate links.